Publications
Book
-
2018
La compétence fiscale
Dalloz, Nouvelle bibliothèque de thèses, 2018
Based on an analysis of State practice and international case law, the Ph.D. demonstrates that the power to tax is rooted in the State and that international law only provides a weak framework for its exercise.
Edited volumes and issues
-
Forthcoming
Les espaces de l'imposition
Revue européenne et internationale de droit fiscal
Ce dossier thématique inclut les contributions suivantes: I/ Délimiter les espaces de l’imposition 1/ Nevia Kallay Čičin-Šain, Territory and territorial extensions in EU VAT 2/ Erika Isabella Scuderi, Taxation and Continental Shelf: A comment on the decision of the Italian Corte di Cassazione, Sez. Read more of the abstract
V, no. 14549/2025 3/ Caroline Chamard-Heim, Les espaces publics d’exception à la norme fiscale II/ Articuler les ordres juridiques dans l’espace 4/ Margo Villeroy, L’impôt face à la pluralité des espaces fiscaux : l’exemple de l’octroi de mer 5/ Marco Greggi, Territoriality and Taxation: the case of San Marino III/ Recomposer les rattachements fiscaux 6/ Benjamin Beer et Filip Debelva, Extraterritoriality and the UTPR in the post Side-by-Side World 7/ Ariane Périn-Dureau, La portée territoriale de l’IS et la répartition conventionnelle du droit d’imposer : quelle(s) évolution(s) pour le concept de résidence ?
Articles
-
2026
Les espaces de l'imposition: introduction
Revue européenne et internationale de droit fiscal, 2026, no. 2, p. 191
That a State’s fiscal territory does not coincide with its political territory is not a new observation, but the gap is widening under the effect of globalised trade, fragmented value chains, the dematerialisation of economic activity and interstate cooperation and integration. Read more of the abstract
The reference to “spaces” of taxation seeks to capture the configurations in which fiscal jurisdiction is allocated, limited, coordinated or subject to exceptions, and through which a taxpayer, an item of income or an asset is connected to a given legal order. This introduction presents the seven contributions to the themed section along three lines: the delimitation of the spaces of taxation (EU VAT, the continental shelf, tax immunities of foreign or international public property), the interplay of distinct legal orders within the same geographical space (dock dues (octroi de mer), San Marino), and the reshaping of tax connecting factors in the face of fragmented economic activity (the undertaxed profits rule, the residence of legal persons).
-
2026
Democratic Control Over Tax Treaties: A Comparative Constitutional Perspective
World Tax Journal, 2026, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 37-82
The article asks a fundamental constitutional question: who democratically controls tax treaty policy? Read more of the abstract
Using a functional, lifecycle-based comparative method, it examines four pivotal moments at which representative consent may shape or limit tax treaty commitments: entry (negotiation and approval), clarification (reservations, subsequent agreements, interpretative practice), operation (domestic implementation and application, including override), and exit (termination). Although tax treaties reallocate taxing right, reshape tax bases and affect public revenue, the comparative analysis of selected civil-law and common-law jurisdictions reveals a recurring pattern of executive dominance. Parliaments play a central but temporarily compressed role at approval or implementation, but they are only weakly integrated into the management and evolution of treaty commitments. The article maps emerging best practices and advances a reform agenda aimed at re-embedding tax treaties within domestic chains of democratic legitimacy, so that the principle of “no taxation without representation” applies coherently to both international tax commitment and ordinary tax legislation.
-
2026
Une appréciation critique de l'impôt Zucman
Revue de droit fiscal, 2026, no. 5
This article offers a legal characterisation of the proposal for a minimum tax on ultra-high net worth individuals. Read more of the abstract
Although presented as a wealth tax, the project submitted to the G20 in 2024 operates as a hybrid corrective mechanism built on deemed income and anchored in a notion of “economic income”. This conceptual shift moves the benchmark of tax burden from realised income to the wealth stock. The proposed tax base neutralises certain wealth-structuring strategies in abstracto, replacing a case-by-case anti-avoidance logic with a general minimum-tax threshold. The debate therefore shifts from the characterisation of abuse of law to the legitimacy of minimum taxation of net wealth. Turning the average return on capital (2%) observed over forty years into a rule of law creates a potential disconnect between tax liability and realised or disposable income, raising liquidity issues and a risk of excessive taxation unless corrective mechanisms are introduced (capping mechanism; rebuttable presumption). Dutch “Box 3” case-law illustrates the vulnerability of notional income taxation when the fiction may exceed reality. “Payment in kind” through the transfer of shares, presented as a liquidity solution, is legally ambivalent: it may entail forced dilution of shareholding structures and in tension with fundamental freedoms, especially for private (non-listed) participations. The effectiveness conditions for such a regime are not currently met: it requires significantly stronger information and traceability of assets (including non-financial assets), as well as a coherent method for crediting foreign taxes. The claimed parallel with Pillar Two is moreover fragile for individuals, not least in the absence of an individual “consolidated” accounting baseline. Finally, the mechanism presupposes an unlimited residence-state taxing power over worldwide wealth: it therefore sits outside the architecture of bilateral tax treaties and is in tension with ongoing UN work on wealth taxation, which tends towards an allocation-based approach to taxing rights.
-
2025
Récupération des aides d’État illégales : autonomie procédurale, continuité économique et confiance légitime
Doctrine.fr, 2025
The French Conseil d'Etat reverses previous case law on the prescription period for the recovery of illegal state aid and, at the same time, clarifies the conditions under which legitimate expectations may be invoked. Read more of the abstract
According to the principles of economic continuity and economic unity, the purchase at market price of a company that has received illegal aid does not protect the purchaser from the obligation to return the aid. Subject to the effectiveness of EU law, the principle of procedural autonomy applies in internal procedures for the recovery of illegal aid. In those proceedings, the objective of restoring free competition within the internal market determines the scope of the protection of legitimate expectations.
-
2025
Le contrôle européen des aides d’État comme remède à la non-imposition internationale
Revue des Affaires européennes/Law European & Affairs, 2025, vol. 2024, no. 4, pp. 811-823
According to the European Commission, Ireland had granted illegal State aid to the Apple group through tax rulings relating to the tax treatment of profits derived from Apple’s activities outside the United States. Read more of the abstract
The Court of Justice of the European Union held that the General Court, which had annulled the Commission’s decision, had erred in holding that the Commission had not sufficiently demonstrated that the IP licenses held by the Irish subsidiaries and the associated profits were to be allocated to their Irish branches. In particular, the General Court erred in holding that the Commission’s main argument was based on incorrect assessments of the normal taxation under Irish law. In particular, the CJEU confirmed the Commission’s approach that the activities of the Irish branches should be compared not with the activities of the parent company Apple Inc. but with those of the head offices of the Irish subsidiaries. Discussing the usefulness of EU State aid procedures for addressing competition distortions related with companies of non-EU countries, the article shows that the Court’s ruling has a limited scope and does not overturn the Court’s previous case-law in State aid matters. Meanwhile, it also suggests that the Court’s reasoning is based on a questionable use of the “Authorized OECD Approach” for the attribution of profits to permanent establishments, on an erroneous interpretation of the OECD principles and on an approach “by exclusion”, relaxing thereby the burden of proof in State aid procedures.
-
2025
Les bénéfices non distribués d’une filiale étrangère: des revenus innommés ?
Fiscalité internationale, 2025, no. 2, pp. 240-247
Since it was redrafted in 2005, Article 209 B of the French General Tax Code deems that the profits of a controlled foreign subsidiary located in a low-tax jurisdiction are distributed and are therefore taxed in France as income from transferable securities. Read more of the abstract
Interpreting terms undefined in the France/Mauritius DTC by reference to domestic law, the French Supreme administrative Court qualified this income under the “other income” treaty clause, thereby acknowledging France's jurisdiction as the State of residence of the parent company. While this solution reflects the evolution of the OECD model commentaries and is consistent with customary international law and the constitutional framework, it nonetheless raises the question of the limits of application of the “other income” clause and of an alternative classification of such income under tax treaty law.
-
2025
Répartition des coûts du mécanisme de capacité du système électrique
Revue de droit fiscal, 2025, no. 10
-
2024
Droit comptable et notion juridique de propriété
Revue du droit public et de la science politique en France et à l'étranger, 2024, no. 4, pp. 169-174
In order to represent accurately the assets of public bodies, public accounting law is based on the private law concept of asset, which differs from the concept of property. Read more of the abstract
Without disregarding legal ownership, assets can go beyond it and sometimes even ignore it in favour of economic ownership.
-
2024
Concessions d'autoroutes : une taxe non spécifique?
Revue de droit fiscal, 2024, no. 48, étude 379
In an attempt to control the profitability of highway concessions, deemed to be excessive, the French legislature adopted a tax that was supposedly not specific to these companies. Read more of the abstract
From a constitutional point of view, the adoption of this tax disregards the constitutional requirements incumbent on the legislature. From an administrative point of view, because it disrupts the performance of the concession contracts, it raises the question of the applicability of the compensation clause in those contracts and could give rise to no-fault liability of the State as legislator. From a treaty point of view, it could disregard France's commitments under the European Convention on Human Rights, thereby undermining the legitimate expectations of concessionaires.
-
2023
La saisie des créances fiscales d'un Etat étranger en France
Journal du droit international (Clunet), 2023, no. 4, pp. 1314-1330
In a ruling issued on 13 April 2023 and set against the backdrop of the complex Commisimpex litigation saga, the Cour de cassation held that a foreign State’s general waiver of immunity from enforcement allows any enforcement measure to be taken against a debtor of that State located in France, including the seizure of the foreign State’s tax claims in the hands of that debtor. Read more of the abstract
While this solution is very favourable to the creditors of foreign States whose taxpayers are established in France, it can also be a source of difficulties for the foreign establishments of French companies. The article shows the weakness of the reasoning and the incompleteness of the method used by the French Supreme Civil Court in civil enforcement proceedings against foreign States and their assets.
-
2022
La liste européenne d'Etats non coopératifs à des fins fiscales: étude contentieuse
Revue du droit public et de la science politique en France et à l'étranger, 2022, no. 6, pp. 1669-1719
Inspired by French and EU case law on challenging soft law, this study aims to answer the following question: if the effects of inclusion in the EU list of non-cooperative tax jurisdictions can be important both for third countries and for those who conduct financial flows to or from these countries, is it possible to challenge this listing or its effects? Read more of the abstract
In the first place, the impact of the list is far more important than the stigma attached to a third country for its failure to implement "good tax governance" standards. As a soft law technique, the list allows the EU to drive its external tax strategy while suggesting defensive tax and non-tax measures. Justified by the EU's internal competence to regulate the movement of capital between the EU and third countries, it paves the way for an exclusive external competence of the EU in this area. Secondly, as the list is the result of a non-decision-making act, its updates are not subject to annulment. However, it is possible to consider a preliminary reference for interpretation or assessment of the validity of this act or of the related law on which it is based. Finally, as a basis for national defensive measures, the list may be the origin of a review of the compatibility of these measures with European and international economic law.
-
2022
L'imposition mondiale minimale effective à l'épreuve du droit international fiscal conventionnel
Revue européenne et internationale de droit fiscal, 2022, no. 3, pp. 288-300
The article is based on an analysis of the OECD/G20 "Pillar Two" blueprint and model rules under the prism of international tax treaties. Read more of the abstract
It shows that the project promoting an effective global taxation of multinational companies is based on a new conception of tax base allocation between States. While the OECD maintains that the project is compatible with tax treaties to avoid the preparation of a new multilateral treaty, the study shows that this new design is threefold incompatible with tax treaties: “Pillar Two” is incompatible with the treaty principles of allocation of the tax base, the scope of treaty-based distributive rules as well as of the non-discrimination clause.
-
2022
L'applicabilité des traités bilatéraux d'investissement dans les zones contestées
Journal du droit international (Clunet), 2022, no. 3, pp. 825-857
This paper aims to determine the applicable bilateral investment treaty for the protection of investments in disputed areas and to assess the potential pitfalls in the jurisdiction of arbitral tribunals dealing with claims for compensation for alleged damages suffered by foreign investors. Read more of the abstract
It reveals that the definition of « territory » in bilateral investment treaties refers only to the scope of these treaties and is not identical with the definition of territory which serves as basis for sovereignty. A wide range of territorial situations in which these treaties are likely to produce effects can then be observed. The paper further suggests that the inapplication of such treaties in relation to disputed areas, while neither prejudging nor promoting the resolution of the underlying territorial dispute, has no effect on the obligation of non-recognition of internationally wrongful situations. Finally, it shows that the jurisdiction of arbitral tribunals dealing with investment disputes in such zones cannot be ousted either by the objection of the indispensable party or by the respondent party's default in the proceedings.
-
2021
La participation de personnes privées aux activités régaliennes: le cas du recouvrement de l'impôt
Revue française de droit administratif, 2021, pp. 1129-1150
The article argues that the distinctive nature of certain activities traditionally carried out by public persons is not only proven when they are unavailable for devolution, but also when such devolution is allowed. Read more of the abstract
The article shows more precisely how administrative law allows and frames the devolution of these activities. Such private participation is governed by a very particular regime for the State, for the private participant and even for third parties.
-
2019
L'autonomie fiscale de l'Union européenne
Revue des Affaires européennes/Law European & Affairs, 2019, no. 4, pp. 587-697
Analysis of substantive law reveals that the tax autonomy of the European Union does not exist: the Union is a non-sovereign political form whose power to raise taxes is limited. Read more of the abstract
It is necessary to determine the nature of the European tax before considering the forms it could eventually take.
-
2019
L'autonomie fiscale infra-étatique
Revue européenne et internationale de droit fiscal, 2019, no. 1, pp. 19-27
Subnational tax autonomy contributes to the study of political forms: its recognition and its denial reveal political objectives that drive those forms, but do not make it possible to characterise their nature.
-
2019
L'élaboration de la norme fiscale
Revue française de finances publiques, 2019, no. 146, pp. 59-70
Analysis of the creation of rules applying to cross-border tax situations shows an unchanging identity of rule-makers and a fluctuation of aims borne by these rules.
-
2019
La convention multilatérale de l'OCDE et les conventions fiscales bilatérales
Lexbase Hebdo, 2019, no. 768, N7167BXQ
The study brings out the specific character of the multilateral convention opened for signature on 7 June 2017 within the category of multilateral international treaties, as well as its singularity among the instruments of international tax law.
-
2018
L'extraterritorialité en matière fiscale
Cahiers de droit de l'entreprise, 2018, no. 4, p. 52
The study suggests that giving effect to tax rules with extraterritorial reach does not breach the international principle of non-intervention, while the foreign State is free to declare them unenforceable against it.
-
2015
Citizenship and Taxation in France
European Taxation, 2015, vol. 55, no. 5, pp. 196-200
The article examines the 2013 tax treaty between Andorra and France, which includes a specific clause aimed at combating the effects of "tax exile" by means of potential taxation based on citizenship.
Full text on HAL · DOI · SSRN
-
2013
Some Thoughts on Taxable Capacity and Confiscatory Taxation after the French Constitutional Court's decision 2012-662 D.C.
Diritto e pratica tributaria internazionale, 2013, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 105-136
An analysis of the principle of ability to pay through the tax case law of the French Constitutional Court shows that any guarantee of non-confiscation is fragile when it is based on statutory law.
Chapters and entries
-
Forthcoming
Taxing Employment Income in France
in G. Maisto (ed.), Employment Income under Domestic Law, EU Law and Tax Treaties, IBFD
French law taxes employment income through domestic categories wider than employment in the labour-law sense. Read more of the abstract
The administrative courts carry those categories into treaty interpretation. The chapter examines the withholding taxes on non-resident employees, the location in France of the activity of directors of French companies, the treatment of social contributions (CSG and CRDS) under tax treaties and EU social security coordination, and cross-border telework. The common thread is the protection of the French tax base as source State for directors and as residence State for frontier workers.
-
2026
Le contrôle européen des subventions étrangères sous forme fiscale
in Christophe de la Mardière, Laurence Vapaille (ed.), Mélanges en l'honneur de Thierry Lambert, Bruylant, 2026, pp. 415-432
This article argues that the Foreign Subsidies Regulation significantly expands European scrutiny of foreign fiscal advantages by combining concepts drawn from EU State aid law and WTO subsidy law. Read more of the abstract
While it usefully fills a gap in the protection of competition on the internal market, its implementation must remain proportionate so as not to unduly undermine legal certainty for businesses.
-
Forthcoming
Les usages de l’instrument tarifaire par l’Union européenne : entre logique corrective et logique de riposte
in Ludovic Ayrault (ed.), Le droit de douane, IRJS
The article analyses the EU's uses of the tariff instrument, between a corrective logic — trade defence, control of foreign subsidies, rebalancing measures — and a retaliatory logic — the Anti-Coercion Instrument, the tariff dimension of restrictive measures, GSP conditionality. Read more of the abstract
It examines successively their internal coherence, in the light of EU law, and their external coherence, in the light of the WTO multilateral framework, general international law of State responsibility, and the Union's network of preferential agreements. The study incorporates recent developments (countervailing duties on Chinese battery electric vehicles, the Hengshi/Jushi judgment and Panel report DS616 on transnational subsidy attribution, the political activation of the Anti-Coercion Instrument during the Greenland crisis, the invalidation of IEEPA tariffs by the U.S. Supreme Court in Learning Resources v. Trump, and the transposition into EU law of the Turnberry arrangement) to argue that the legal articulation of the EU's tariff instruments is robust, but that the coherence of the Union's tariff policy now depends less on the legal availability of these instruments than on the political will to mobilise them.
-
2025
Le Parlement et les engagements internationaux fiscaux
in M. Masclet de Barbarin (éd.), Le Parlement et l'impôt, Larcier, CEFF - Université Aix-Marseille, 2025
Parliament’s role with regard to international tax commitments lies in the interstices of executive action. Read more of the abstract
At the treaty-making stage, Parliament may be called upon to pass an authorising act, in particular where the agreement falls within the domain reserved to statute or commits the finances of the State. Case law and administrative practice have, however, adopted a restrictive reading of these notions, leaving various agreements of fiscal interest outside the scope of Article 53 of the Constitution. Moreover, Parliament’s inability to amend treaty provisions, the rarity with which bills authorising approval are rejected and the weakness of impact assessments deprive it of substantial involvement. At the implementation stage, the French legal order, monist by tradition, gives duly ratified international commitments an authority superior to that of statutes. Parliament nevertheless remains external to the actual application of treaty rules, save where legislative transposition is required. A comparison with other legal systems (United States, Germany, United Kingdom, Switzerland) brings out various ways of receiving tax treaty law into the domestic legal order, ranging from primacy over statute to equality with it or subordination to it. Finally, as regards termination, in the absence of an express constitutional provision, denunciation falls within the reserved domain of the executive. Some foreign systems (Russia, Denmark, Sweden) nonetheless require parliamentary authorisation to terminate a treaty, reflecting a concern for parallelism of forms between the conclusion and the termination of commitments, and for respect of the democratic principle.
-
2024
The Other Income Clause in French Tax Treaties
in Guglielmo Maisto (ed.), Revisiting Article 21 (Other Income) of the OECD Model Convention, IBFD, EC and International Tax Law Series, vol. 21, 2024, pp. 395-426
The article explores the evolution of France’s approach to Article 21 of the OECD Model, shedding light on the policy rationale underlying this practice. Read more of the abstract
It begins by analysing the categories of income addressed by Article 21 within French treaties and examines how this article interacts with other distributive rules in French treaty practice, drawing insights from the OECD Model. In greater depth, the article investigates the interplay between the “other income” provision and specific income types, including fictitious income, business income, investment income, capital gains, trust-derived income, and government service income. Additionally, it examines how the “other income” provision in French tax treaties applies to income from third states. The article then considers the impact of the “other income” provision within the UN Model on French treaty practice, paying particular attention to notable deviations.
Full text on HAL · DOI · SSRN
-
2024
Le champ d'application territorial des conventions fiscales internationales
Encyclopédie Fiscalité internationale, Doctrine, 2024
The determination of the territorial scope of application of international tax treaties depends on geographical, political and temporal considerations of the contracting State, which lead to an alignment of the spatial scope of the tax system of the contracting State with the territorial scope of treaties.
-
2024
La compétence de recouvrer l’imposition peut-elle être conférée à un organe non étatique ? Point de vue français
in IRJS (ed.), L. Ayrault (dir.), Le recouvrement de l’imposition. Actes des journées des 7 et 8 avril 2022, 2024, pp. 59-71
The incomplete definition of what public action may not be delegated makes it possible for private persons to collect taxes in France. Read more of the abstract
The contribution examines the constitutional and statutory grounds for such delegation, the forms of private participation, based on statute or on contracts authorised by statute, and its regime. Although motivated by economy or efficiency, recourse to private persons is not without risks for public entities, private third parties and members of the public.
-
2021
Contribution to Taxpayers in International Law
in J. Kokott, P. Pistone (ed.), Taxpayers in International Law: International Minimum Standards for the Protection of Taxpayers’ Rights, Hart, 2021
-
2019
Report on the Schneider Electric case law (Conseil d’Etat, 28 June 2002, no. 232276)
A. Noelkaemper, A. Reinisch (dir.), Oxford Reports on International Law in Domestic Courts, 2019
This report analyses the Schneider Electric decision of the Conseil d’État (28 June 2002) on whether the France/Switzerland double taxation convention could be the direct legal basis of tax liability in France. Read more of the abstract
It examines the so-called principle of “subsidiarity” of tax treaties, the methods of interpretation of the French courts and the later case law on the relationship between domestic law and tax treaties.
Reports
-
2019
BiHaCoTax - Bilateral Harmonisation Approach in Company Taxation. A comparative legal analysis between the German and French tax systems
Université Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne, Osnabrück University, 2019. With Daniel Gutmann, Steffen Lampert, Ludovic Ayrault, Lars Marquardsen
Against a backdrop of reflection on the harmonisation of corporate taxation within the European Union, the aim of the research project was to assess whether corporate taxation in France and Germany could be brought closer together through bilateral cooperation between the two States outside the institutionalised framework of the European Union. Read more of the abstract
The objectives of the research project were twofold. Following on from the "Green Paper on Franco-German cooperation concerning points of convergence on company taxation", published in 2012 by the French and German finance ministries, the aim of the study was to assess the structural (constitutional, in particular) and technical (in view of the tax techniques existing in the two countries) possibilities for harmonising legal rules on company taxation. In retrospect, this approach appears all the more justified given that France and Germany published a joint position on the European Commission's proposal for a directive on the common corporate tax base on 19 June 2018. In addition, on 22 January 2019, France and Germany signed the Treaty on Franco-German Cooperation and Integration, Article 1 of which aims to promote "economic, fiscal and social convergence", and Article 20 of which aims to promote "the bilateral harmonisation of their legislation, in particular in the field of company law". The steering committee of the project, which brought together French and German researchers, contributed to the construction of questionnaires in English to carry out a comparative analysis of the two tax systems in order to identify the consistency of the constitutional and non-constitutional principles and objectives applicable to the direct taxation of companies in France and Germany, in order to detect the common points and differences between the two legal systems. It emerged from this stage that there was a similarity between the French and German systems that made it possible to examine the harmonisation of direct company taxation rules. Another questionnaire was then drawn up to compare the general structure of corporation tax in the two countries, as well as the technical rules governing the determination of taxable income and the computation of tax in the two countries. Using the questionnaire method followed by a comparative analysis, the study systematically highlighted the similarities and differences between the rules applicable to company taxation in France and Germany. The result is that the constitutional framework in the two countries is very similar, but the stakes involved in the differences are significant. From a technical point of view, the main principles of company taxation are the same in both countries, but there are still major differences in the applicable techniques, so that harmonisation of the two systems would have a considerable impact on tax legislation and practice.
-
2018
Rapport français, « Impôts, aides d'État et distorsions de la concurrence », Congrès de la FIDE 2018
FIDE, 2018. With Francesco Martucci, Stéphane de La Rosa, Charles Vautrot-Schwarz, Claire Vannini, Ioanna Papadamaki
Answers to questions 2 (with Charles Vautrot-Schwarz), 3 and 14 of the questionnaire, on the verification by the tax authorities of the facts set out in a ruling request, on the verification of the treatment given by the other State to a payment or transaction, and on the courts’ approach to conflicting obligations under EU law and international law, including bilateral agreements with non-EU States.