Publications · Articles
La liste européenne d'Etats non coopératifs à des fins fiscales: étude contentieuse
The EU list of non cooperating jurisdictions for tax purposes: a litigation-oriented analysis
Revue du droit public et de la science politique en France et à l'étranger, 2022, no. 6, pp. 1669-1719
Abstract
Inspired by French and EU case law on challenging soft law, this study aims to answer the following question: if the effects of inclusion in the EU list of non-cooperative tax jurisdictions can be important both for third countries and for those who conduct financial flows to or from these countries, is it possible to challenge this listing or its effects? In the first place, the impact of the list is far more important than the stigma attached to a third country for its failure to implement "good tax governance" standards. As a soft law technique, the list allows the EU to drive its external tax strategy while suggesting defensive tax and non-tax measures. Justified by the EU's internal competence to regulate the movement of capital between the EU and third countries, it paves the way for an exclusive external competence of the EU in this area. Secondly, as the list is the result of a non-decision-making act, its updates are not subject to annulment. However, it is possible to consider a preliminary reference for interpretation or assessment of the validity of this act or of the related law on which it is based. Finally, as a basis for national defensive measures, the list may be the origin of a review of the compatibility of these measures with European and international economic law.