Skip to content
Andreas Kallergis Français

Publications · Chapters and entries

Le Parlement et les engagements internationaux fiscaux

National Parliaments and international tax treaties

in M. Masclet de Barbarin (éd.), Le Parlement et l'impôt, Larcier, CEFF - Université Aix-Marseille, 2025

Abstract

Parliament’s role with regard to international tax commitments lies in the interstices of executive action. At the treaty-making stage, Parliament may be called upon to pass an authorising act, in particular where the agreement falls within the domain reserved to statute or commits the finances of the State. Case law and administrative practice have, however, adopted a restrictive reading of these notions, leaving various agreements of fiscal interest outside the scope of Article 53 of the Constitution. Moreover, Parliament’s inability to amend treaty provisions, the rarity with which bills authorising approval are rejected and the weakness of impact assessments deprive it of substantial involvement. At the implementation stage, the French legal order, monist by tradition, gives duly ratified international commitments an authority superior to that of statutes. Parliament nevertheless remains external to the actual application of treaty rules, save where legislative transposition is required. A comparison with other legal systems (United States, Germany, United Kingdom, Switzerland) brings out various ways of receiving tax treaty law into the domestic legal order, ranging from primacy over statute to equality with it or subordination to it. Finally, as regards termination, in the absence of an express constitutional provision, denunciation falls within the reserved domain of the executive. Some foreign systems (Russia, Denmark, Sweden) nonetheless require parliamentary authorisation to terminate a treaty, reflecting a concern for parallelism of forms between the conclusion and the termination of commitments, and for respect of the democratic principle.