Publications · Articles
Une appréciation critique de l'impôt Zucman
A Critical Assessment of the “Zucman Tax”
Revue de droit fiscal, 2026, no. 5
Abstract
This article offers a legal characterisation of the proposal for a minimum tax on ultra-high net worth individuals. Although presented as a wealth tax, the project submitted to the G20 in 2024 operates as a hybrid corrective mechanism built on deemed income and anchored in a notion of “economic income”. This conceptual shift moves the benchmark of tax burden from realised income to the wealth stock. The proposed tax base neutralises certain wealth-structuring strategies in abstracto, replacing a case-by-case anti-avoidance logic with a general minimum-tax threshold. The debate therefore shifts from the characterisation of abuse of law to the legitimacy of minimum taxation of net wealth. Turning the average return on capital (2%) observed over forty years into a rule of law creates a potential disconnect between tax liability and realised or disposable income, raising liquidity issues and a risk of excessive taxation unless corrective mechanisms are introduced (capping mechanism; rebuttable presumption). Dutch “Box 3” case-law illustrates the vulnerability of notional income taxation when the fiction may exceed reality. “Payment in kind” through the transfer of shares, presented as a liquidity solution, is legally ambivalent: it may entail forced dilution of shareholding structures and in tension with fundamental freedoms, especially for private (non-listed) participations. The effectiveness conditions for such a regime are not currently met: it requires significantly stronger information and traceability of assets (including non-financial assets), as well as a coherent method for crediting foreign taxes. The claimed parallel with Pillar Two is moreover fragile for individuals, not least in the absence of an individual “consolidated” accounting baseline. Finally, the mechanism presupposes an unlimited residence-state taxing power over worldwide wealth: it therefore sits outside the architecture of bilateral tax treaties and is in tension with ongoing UN work on wealth taxation, which tends towards an allocation-based approach to taxing rights.