Skip to content
Andreas Kallergis Français

Publications · Articles

L'applicabilité des traités bilatéraux d'investissement dans les zones contestées

The applicability of bilateral investment treaties in disputed areas

Journal du droit international (Clunet), 2022, no. 3, pp. 825-857

Abstract

This paper aims to determine the applicable bilateral investment treaty for the protection of investments in disputed areas and to assess the potential pitfalls in the jurisdiction of arbitral tribunals dealing with claims for compensation for alleged damages suffered by foreign investors. It reveals that the definition of « territory » in bilateral investment treaties refers only to the scope of these treaties and is not identical with the definition of territory which serves as basis for sovereignty. A wide range of territorial situations in which these treaties are likely to produce effects can then be observed. The paper further suggests that the inapplication of such treaties in relation to disputed areas, while neither prejudging nor promoting the resolution of the underlying territorial dispute, has no effect on the obligation of non-recognition of internationally wrongful situations. Finally, it shows that the jurisdiction of arbitral tribunals dealing with investment disputes in such zones cannot be ousted either by the objection of the indispensable party or by the respondent party's default in the proceedings.